With Thanksgiving just around the corner, I have food on my mind. I always have food on my mind, but especially so in this later half of November.
One of my great joys in life is sharing food with people I love. Another great joy is seeing those same people enjoy something I made. Thanksgiving is the perfect holiday to experience those two great joys.
Which inevitably makes me remember the worst Thanksgiving dinner I ever made for my family. My whole, extended family.
My wife and I wanted to host Thanksgiving at our house, because we love having company and experiencing those two great joys I just mentioned. I also wanted to prove to my extended family that a homemade vegan dinner could rival traditional fare. This I pitched to them ahead of time, and they agreed. They were going to give me a chance.
And boy oh boy, did I absolutely blow it.
I found a recipe for a “Thanksgiving roast” in one of my many vegan recipe books. It made heavy use of textured vegetable protein, which I’d used before in another cookbook’s recipe and I rather enjoyed it. This was a recipe I’d never tried before, but upon reading the ingredients and process I felt confident it would come together. It did not.
The end result was a spongey lump of… something… that looked as bland as it tasted. It looked like the kind of thing that people make jokes about vegans eating instead of “the real thing,” and it would be hard to refute this abomination as evidence of that stereotype.
Nobody liked it. Not even me. After years of doing panels at conventions and keeping crowds entertained I feel like I’ve grown pretty good at reading the room, and what I was reading was polite but awkward silence, in that sort of “let’s all agree to get through this and never speak of it again.” My brother was the only one who went back for seconds, but I suspect he was doing it to be nice. I didn’t even want a second helping of that thing.
On top of that, I got the sides all wrong, but at least that was because I misread personal tastes, as opposed to it coming out badly.
I roast Brussel sprouts quite well, and they always come out tasty. My father, a famously adventurous eater, had told us for years that the only thing he hated eating was sprouts. Now I thought that was just because 1) his parents’ generation had no idea how to properly cook vegetables aside from boiling them, and 2) modern Brussel sprouts are actually a different variety than the nasty tasting ones he had to endure.
So when I served my roasted, seasoned, delicate sprouts I was convinced I could win him and everyone else over to this stereotypically maligned vegetable! Nope. Even properly cooked, seasoned, and modernized, there was just no getting over childhood aversion.
Needless to say, I was really deflated after that, and I haven’t attempted to be the sole cook for a holiday dinner since. To their credit, no one said anything to my face, but I know how to read a room, and the reading I got was disappointment. Most of it was probably radiating off of me, to be fair.
I’m not a bad cook. I know I’m not. I’ve gotten my picky-eating kid to eat and enjoy Brussel sprouts, broccoli, collard greens, and kale. I make a mean curry dish that I made up from scratch. I served chickpea-and-veggie burritos last summer that wowed all my friends and had them all eagerly going back for seconds. I contributed another Brussel sprouts recipe as a side for a big Christmas Eve dinner last year that was very well received.
But I don’t think anyone trusts me to be “the cook” for the holidays again, least of all myself. Not after that disaster. Not after the worst thing I ever made for a holiday that means a lot to me, for the people who mean a great deal to me.
I threw that goddamn cookbook away, too.
